Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils (24ct) Review

Quick Verdict

The Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils 24-piece set earns its shelf space by solving a real problem: kids who get frustrated by coloring mistakes. After a week of testing with a mix of ages, I found the eraser tip genuinely useful, the color range genuinely pleasing, and the pre-sharpened convenience genuinely welcome. They are not artist-grade pencils — the cores are modest and the barrel is short — but for their intended audience, none of that matters. Rating: 4.3 out of 5.

What Is the Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils?

These are wood-cased colored pencils, each fitted with a small but functional eraser tip at the opposite end from the lead. The set includes 24 colors in a tuck-top resealable box. Crayola positions them as an everyday creative tool for kids — the kind of thing that lives in a backpack, gets tossed in a Christmas stocking, or sits on a classroom supply shelf. They are pre-sharpened at the factory, which means you open the box and start coloring. No sharpening required, no guessing whether the set you received is sharpened or not.

The core formulation is wax-based, which is standard for colored pencils in this price tier. The pigment load is lighter than professional-grade alternatives, but the colors are well-chosen and cover a practical range — from warm yellows and oranges through cool greens, blues, and a serviceable range of skin-tone-adjacent shades. There is a purple that leans slightly magenta and a green that is almost kelly, both of which are easy to reach for when a kid wants a particular look.

Key Features

• 24 erasable colored pencils in a resealable tuck-top box
• Pre-sharpened at the factory — ready to use immediately
• Small but effective eraser tip on each pencil
• 24 rich, vibrant colors with good differentiation across the palette
• Smooth wax-based laydown on standard drawing and coloring book paper
• Suitable for ages 6 and up
• Typical barrel length — compact but usable for small hands

Hands-On Review

I sat down with a seven-year-old who had zero patience for correction tape and a half-finished nature coloring book. The first thing I noticed was the weight of the box — it has a satisfying heft, and the resealable flap actually seals without fighting you. By the end of the first page, she had used the eraser tip three times. Each correction took about three seconds of rubbing and left the paper clean enough that she did not feel the need to abandon the page entirely. That alone justified the set's existence, in my opinion.

What surprised me was the color vibrancy. I expected the typical Crayola palette — serviceable, predictable, a little flat. Instead, the orange genuinely pops, the cobalt blue goes on dark without needing three passes, and the magenta sits between fuchsia and berry in a way that is easy to pair with other shades. The core glides smoothly on the 100gsm paper I tested with; there is no wax drag, no squeak, no skipping. Layering works reasonably well for the first two passes before the wax starts to pill. That is not a flaw — it is exactly what you should expect from a pencil in this class.

After about a week of daily use, two of the darker pencils — the navy and the forest green — developed small chips at the barrel junction near the ferrule. This is cosmetic and did not affect performance. The eraser tip on the blue pencil started showing slight wear after the third day of heavy use, flattening slightly at the contact point. Still functional, just less precise on fine lines.

There is one thing nobody mentions in the listings: the barrel length is noticeably shorter than a standard artist colored pencil. Adults using these for more than five minutes will feel it in their grip. For kids ages 6 through 10, it is not an issue at all.

Who Should Buy It?

These pencils are worth your money if:

• You are buying for a child aged 6 to 10 who colors frequently and gets discouraged by mistakes. The eraser tip is a genuine stress reducer, not a marketing gimmick.
• You are a teacher or homeschool parent looking for a classroom-friendly set. The resealable box, pre-sharpened tips, and forgiving nature make these practical for group settings.
• You want a reliable gift option that does not require assembly or wrapping guesswork. The box looks presentable and the age rating is clearly marked.
• You are an adult who occasionally color-swatches or likes to test palettes before committing with expensive art supplies. The 24-color range is wide enough to be useful as a travel or reference set.

Skip these if you are an adult artist who needs heavy layering, archival-quality pigment, or a comfortable full-length barrel. There are better options in the $20–$40 range for serious adult coloring enthusiasts, and these are not trying to compete in that space.

Alternatives Worth Considering

Crayola Supertips 100 — If your priority is sheer color range over erasing capability. Supertips are fineliner-style markers with no tip to dry out, and the 100-color set is almost overwhelming in the best way. Erasability is zero, though.

Prismacolor Premier Colored Pencils (24ct) — A genuine step up in pigment load, wax formulation, and blending capability. They cost roughly four times as much and are designed for adult colorists, not six-year-olds. The eraser tip, however, does not exist.

Faber-Castell Grip Colored Pencils — A middle-ground option with an ergonomic triangular barrel that many adults find more comfortable. They are not erasable, but the build quality is consistently high and the colors are rich.

FAQ

Final Verdict

The Crayola Erasable Colored Pencils 24-piece set does exactly what it promises: it gives kids (and forgiving adults) a way to correct mistakes without tearing pages, abandoning projects, or losing momentum. The color palette is bright and practical, the eraser tip works, and the pre-sharpened convenience removes one more barrier between a kid and the act of creating. They are not the last pencils an adult artist will ever buy, but they might be the most used set in a household with young children. At their price point, the value proposition is straightforward. If erasing mistakes matters to the person using them, these pencils earn a recommendation.